Posted: Tue Feb 13, 2007 12:13 am
Thanks for the chapter EG.
azn_l10n wrote:And Skull Knight said that not a being of the mortal world can touch Griffith. In order to touch him, you must be out of the Mortal World. Like the forest witch, Gatts, and Ganishka as well.
azn_l10n wrote:An Overlord is not necessarily the most powerful in any sense, berserk is not an alpha dog story. If so, Gatts is dead, end of story. I do not doubt that Griffith is in control and that the emperor is pissing his pants but Gatts won most of his early impossible fights because of desperation. What is to say that Ganishka can't lift a finger?
Two points. First, she basically let him do that (you notice how pleased she was to get stabbed), so you can hardly say that he did it by his own power. Heck, look how she treated him in the first moments, it's obvious she could have killed him anytime she wanted to. Second, the reason he could hurt her was because his sword can harm high-astral beings. If Griffith is still high-astral (which given SK's comments, I expect that he is) then I'm not convinced that the Emperor can even touch him. The fact that he is also a higher astral being then the Emperor ought to let him strike the Emperor's "real" body, without having the trouble others do.Surely, Ganishka is much stronger than Gatts was pre-berserker armor. Gatts with the pre-berserker armor had the power to take down a physical manifestation of the woman god hand. The griffith as we see is also a physical manifestation of Femto (albeit, possibly more because he literally was born here, not just composed of body matter). I wouldn't doubt so easily that Ganishka can do some pain, but I doubt he'll do damage.
Okay, it is possible. And in that possibility, the witch has also pushed herself outside of fate since she mentions having lived past her time. Now, would one say Skull Knight is out of fate as well? In order for the apostles to not be considered out of fate, it would have to be said that Idea is the one that controls fate. Sounds reasonable, because the fate of all humans is death and apostles have escaped that.EnglishJim wrote: This could mean that one must be outside the real world, but it's also possible that Skull Knight was speaking metaphorically about fate.
Fate is similar to a story in that everything is pre-determined. Little things may differ, but the end result is always the same....Therefore, Ganishka cannot hurt Griffith and is fated to lose. However, I do think that Guts has the potential to defeat Griffith. He was destined to die in eclipse as a sacrifice, that's where his fate ended as far as Idea was concerned, but he survived.
I'm pretty sure this won't happen. True, Griffith does try to strengthen his own forces, for the sake of getting a kingdom, but you have to remember that it is for getting the kingdom. Allying with the Emperor would actually hurt that goal (plus I don't see the Emperor going for it) at this point. The Emperor has built up too much hate and animosity against himself, and too many of people think of him as evil incarnate for me to believe that an attempt by Griffith to add him to his forces wouldn't backfire. I'm pretty sure Griffith will just kill him.About Griffith vs. Ganishka: Somehow, I don't think that Griffith will kill Ganishka, if given the chance. Griffith's goal (ever since he got a new body) is to strengthen his forces (thus making it easier for him to gain a kingdom). And Ganishka is one hell of a powerful being (he even defeat Zodd). Not the mention the fact that the Emperor of Kushan does not seem to *hate* Griffith.
I'm pretty sure that you're talking about Silatt.Also, what is the name of the guy that peak on the roof? Somehow, I never remember his name.
I disagree, I think Griffith will basically crush him effortlessly, but I suppose we'll just have to wait and see. At this point I doubt either of us will convince the other, so it's probably best to just wait for the next chapter (or two) and find out for ourselves.About Ganishka not being able to hurt Griffith, I still disagree.
Why? Let's see, I am differentiating between hurt and injure here. I believe that Ganishka may have what is necessary to cause pain but not inflict a wound on Griffith. For example, if I poke you hard enough, you will most likely feel the pain but you certainly won't be injured by my poking (unless you are female, )
That is my point. I think Ganishka actually has enough ability to lay a finger, but not actually do anything with his finger laying.
Uh oh, I hope no crazy feminist catches sight of that...azn_l10n wrote:For example, if I poke you hard enough, you will most likely feel the pain but you certainly won't be injured by my poking (unless you are female,)
It's true that Idea controls destiny, it even says so itself during the eclipse. Admittedly, that particular chapter (A.K.A. The Lost Chapter) was removed from the collected manga, but that was because of a "too much info too early" kinda thing, so I imagine the fact still stands.azn_l10n wrote:Okay, it is possible. And in that possibility, the witch has also pushed herself outside of fate since she mentions having lived past her time. Now, would one say Skull Knight is out of fate as well? In order for the apostles to not be considered out of fate, it would have to be said that Idea is the one that controls fate. Sounds reasonable, because the fate of all humans is death and apostles have escaped that.
NO. The story dies with Miura hopefully(that is he at least leaves the whole plot written in book form, as it seems he takes his time with drawings, before going on to a better life.). I hope Griffith at least offers him a place by his side, or at the least the guy should put up a fight. It would be too cheesy, in my opinion, if he got instant ko.42ndEndOfTheWorld wrote:From now on, you are my overlords![]()
The release is good, although I am a bit disappointed with the way the story turned out. It seems that, after all, Kushan Emperor had no great plan at destroying Griffith, he just lined up all his human troops and hoped for the best. Not a great strategy against godhand, I think. Anyway Ganiska is now in cloud form, which is not all that impressive because we have already seen Guts defeating him in that form, and Griffith is certainly much stronger at a moment.
But on the other hand, Ganiska is meant to be destroyed, so it is kind of logical for him to become drunken with power and overestimate himself, and I am more interested to see what will Griffith do once he gets his kingdom, so maybe this is a wise move from Miura, the story has to end in this century.... right?.....riiight?
nightofchaos wrote:NO. The story dies with Miura hopefully(that is he at least leaves the whole plot written in book form, as it seems he takes his time with drawings, before going on to a better life.). I hope Griffith at least offers him a place by his side, or at the least the guy should put up a fight. It would be too cheesy, in my opinion, if he got instant ko.42ndEndOfTheWorld wrote:From now on, you are my overlords![]()
The release is good, although I am a bit disappointed with the way the story turned out. It seems that, after all, Kushan Emperor had no great plan at destroying Griffith, he just lined up all his human troops and hoped for the best. Not a great strategy against godhand, I think. Anyway Ganiska is now in cloud form, which is not all that impressive because we have already seen Guts defeating him in that form, and Griffith is certainly much stronger at a moment.
But on the other hand, Ganiska is meant to be destroyed, so it is kind of logical for him to become drunken with power and overestimate himself, and I am more interested to see what will Griffith do once he gets his kingdom, so maybe this is a wise move from Miura, the story has to end in this century.... right?.....riiight?
A truce would probably be best, even if he can beat him, it would dishonor the kushan and damage their morale if their king was taken down or bowed before another king. Seeing as he and his troops can hold their own agaisnt most any apostle, they'd make a great asset. Better to have them as foreign allies, who knows what other enemies idea and the godhand may have.
Most likely even the godhand is subject to the laws idea follows, to allow apostles' rights to be respected by members of the godhand. If that is so, the emperor will be asked to make a sacrifice in some metaphorical way, depending on his answer will be griffith's response. I'm pretty sure members of the godhand can't go outright and kill apostles left and right without reason, even if it is to get what they want, there has to be a code of honor amongst them. A law upheld even by the godhand.
Idea doesn't have any enemies, beyond maybe an individual (like Guts) here and there. Idea is the one who manipulates the entire world. Idea created the Emperor solely to give Griffith someone to fight against in order to obtain his dream.A truce would probably be best, even if he can beat him, it would dishonor the kushan and damage their morale if their king was taken down or bowed before another king. Seeing as he and his troops can hold their own agaisnt most any apostle, they'd make a great asset. Better to have them as foreign allies, who knows what other enemies idea and the godhand may have.
Sorry, no. It has been stated several places in the manga that the only command given is "do as you will". Thus Apostles are free to oppose the God's Hand (such as Wyald and the Emperor) and the God's Hand are free to kill Apostles. Mostly Griffith doesn't, but that's a matter of practicality, not law.Most likely even the godhand is subject to the laws idea follows, to allow apostles' rights to be respected by members of the godhand. If that is so, the emperor will be asked to make a sacrifice in some metaphorical way, depending on his answer will be griffith's response. I'm pretty sure members of the godhand can't go outright and kill apostles left and right without reason, even if it is to get what they want, there has to be a code of honor amongst them. A law upheld even by the godhand.
Interesting that was something missing from my dream of an ideal world, I'll be sure to add it. Pure evil left to run free amongst the lands... wonderful! Thanks!Istvan wrote:Idea doesn't have any enemies, beyond maybe an individual (like Guts) here and there. Idea is the one who manipulates the entire world. Idea created the Emperor solely to give Griffith someone to fight against in order to obtain his dream.A truce would probably be best, even if he can beat him, it would dishonor the kushan and damage their morale if their king was taken down or bowed before another king. Seeing as he and his troops can hold their own agaisnt most any apostle, they'd make a great asset. Better to have them as foreign allies, who knows what other enemies idea and the godhand may have.
Sorry, no. It has been stated several places in the manga that the only command given is "do as you will". Thus Apostles are free to oppose the God's Hand (such as Wyald and the Emperor) and the God's Hand are free to kill Apostles. Mostly Griffith doesn't, but that's a matter of practicality, not law.Most likely even the godhand is subject to the laws idea follows, to allow apostles' rights to be respected by members of the godhand. If that is so, the emperor will be asked to make a sacrifice in some metaphorical way, depending on his answer will be griffith's response. I'm pretty sure members of the godhand can't go outright and kill apostles left and right without reason, even if it is to get what they want, there has to be a code of honor amongst them. A law upheld even by the godhand.