Do you consider Miura to be a genius?

[Skullomania]

Don't know if any of you have ever considered or discussed Miura to be a genius ,but we have to admit it he is a very talented guy and especialy for a japanese.I persoanly do not think "HE IS" ,but after every few chapters i'm
getting more and more convinced that this artist is going to make a revolution
,whith his graphic style and method of approach.I do belive that after 10 years his drawing method will slowly approach those of the late renaissance.
What's your opinion?

[Libaax]

Well his art is genious thats for sure.


The first 20 so vols of Berserk was amazing artwise. It was so powerful and dark that i didnt know a manga could look like that.

[Albator]

I'm a genius at hyper self-pleasuring myself.

[LordMune]

I consider him to be an insanely talented storyteller and artist.

He may even qualify as a genius, yes.

[Sandman]

I consider him to be an insanely talented storyteller and artist.

He may even qualify as a genius, yes.

My words exactly, except I would have used the word awesome some where and this

[Istvan]

I would say he's a genius storyteller, at the very least. He's probably (although I don't know for sure) not a genius in the classical sense, but in the realm of storytelling, I'd classify Berserk as a work of genius.

[Gattsblackfalcon]

his drawings are awesome , and the Berserk's story is in my opinion the best you could find in a manga .

[Femto]

As far as storytelling goes, no.

Alan Moore is more of a genius than Miura will ever be in that department.

As far as artwork goes, no.

*insert name of vastly superior comic book artist*

I think bold is a more accurate description of Muira's abilities.

At least it used to be.

[LordMune]

*insert name of vastly superior comic book artist*

Drawing a blank here.

[Sandman]

gen·ius Pronunciation (jnys)
n. pl. gen·ius·es
1.
a. Extraordinary intellectual and creative power.
b. A person of extraordinary intellect and talent: "One is not born a genius, one becomes a genius" Simone de Beauvoir.
c. A person who has an exceptionally high intelligence quotient, typically above 140.
2.
a. A strong natural talent, aptitude, or inclination: has a genius for choosing the right words.
b. One who has such a talent or inclination: a genius at diplomacy.
3. The prevailing spirit or distinctive character, as of a place, a person, or an era: the genius of Elizabethan England.
4. pl. ge·ni·i (jn-) Roman Mythology A tutelary deity or guardian spirit of a person or place.
5. A person who has great influence over another.
6. A jinni in Muslim mythology.
source: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/genius

Here is the definition and yes he is a Genius in my book so take that Femto the Pot stirer

[Femto]

Drawing a blank here.

Bryan Hitch?

Eduardo Risso?

Jim fuckin' Lee?

Miura's artwork is great but I don't usually get the "Wow, this is fucking awesome!" I get from so many other artists.

But that's just me.

An artist's particular style might be more appealing to some than others so there's some subjectivity going on here.

Alan Moore is still just miles and miles above Miura in terms of storytelling though and that's fact, jack.

I've written way too much for this shitty thread.

[Gattsblackfalcon]

hmm , i guess you like a lot more the comic than the manga so that explains the reason of why you say that .

[Sandman]

Opinions are like assholes, every one has one... some just smell better then others, and yours stinks Femto

Edit: Anyway you will be bowing down to Miura when all comes into focus, mark my words

[MrFelony]

you didnt have awesome in your post sandman...im dissapointed. atleast you got the

[Dagda Mor]

Yeah, I'd say a genius in several areas.

[ryusenka]

Miura IS a awesome artist and storyteller if you compare to all the crap manga out there, but he's not the best and everyone has thier own opinions of who's thier favorate artist and what style appeals to them most. He's a great story teller but there are better ones, Naoki Urasawa for example.

Jim fuckin' Lee?

He's fucking overrated.

[Starnum]

Do you consider Miura to be a genius?

Um, yes. Both in art style and story telling.

[Femto]

He's fucking overrated.

Jim Lee can draw whatever the fuck he feels like and that's another fact, jack.

Probably the only big artist from the '90s whose artwork still holds up amazingly today.

Todd McFarlane? Crap.

Rob Liefeld? Crap.

Erik Larsen? I like Savage Dragon, but he's no Jim Lee.

[Eldo]

I consider this thread a waste of time. Now we have a thread 'this artist is better than artist X'.

But really, who draws better is a matter of preference. I think Picasso draws like a fucking drunk, other considers him a genius. Miura is extremely talented in my opinion, not only does he write, he draws the story he created. This isn't like a writer/artist collaboration like American comics. Comparing manga-wise, Berserk has the best artwork I've seen. I personally prefer sketches of Miura's artwork compared to other American artists' sketches.

[t.A]

Don't know if any of you have ever considered or discussed Miura to be a genius..?

eeer nope.

Carl Friedrich Gauss was..
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was..
Albert Einstein was..
Leonardo da Vinci was..
Niels Bohr was..
and many more, but Miura IMHO is talented.

To say the truth in our days while reading the newspaper you can
find that even race horse or rap singer can be titled as "genius" (i
think that horse case is less humorous than the rapers:) ) so in
this kind of environment maybe Miura could be called like this, but
not in the original meaning of the word. More like -"Hey man, you
put on red and yellow socks - you are a genius!" ..

[Femto]

I think Picasso draws like a fucking drunk, other considers him a genius.

But he's not.

[Libaax]

Don't know if any of you have ever considered or discussed Miura to be a genius..?

eeer nope.

Carl Friedrich Gauss was..
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was..
Albert Einstein was..
Leonardo da Vinci was..
Niels Bohr was..
and many more, but Miura IMHO is talented.

To say the truth in our days while reading the newspaper you can
find that even race horse or rap singer can be titled as "genius" (i
think that horse case is less humorous than the rapers:) ) so in
this kind of environment maybe Miura could be called like this, but
not in the original meaning of the word. More like -"Hey man, you
put on red and yellow socks - you are a genius!" ..

I think he is a genius cause there arent anyone near his level when its about art.

Just like there werent anyone in Mozart's time come near his level.

[LordMune]

Hey man, you put on red and yellow socks - you are a genius!

I feel this, bro. Or whatever.

When I say Miura is 'talented', that carries, at least to me, a lot more weight than people nowadays associate with the term 'genius'.

[Libaax]

I consider this thread a waste of time. Now we have a thread 'this artist is better than artist X'.

But really, who draws better is a matter of preference. I think Picasso draws like a fucking drunk, other considers him a genius. Miura is extremely talented in my opinion, not only does he write, he draws the story he created. This isn't like a writer/artist collaboration like American comics. Comparing manga-wise, Berserk has the best artwork I've seen. I personally prefer sketches of Miura's artwork compared to other American artists' sketches.

I am not a fan of Picasso iether but to draw messed up style of his iether he is very very sick or very very genius.


You know whats funny about him, that he was poor most of his life a vagabond living on the little money he made of selling pieces that now go for minium 100 million dollars to the record breaking one of his that sold for 500-600 million dollars.

[Skullomania]

I consider this thread a waste of time. Now we have a thread 'this artist is better than artist X'.

But really, who draws better is a matter of preference. I think Picasso draws like a fucking drunk, other considers him a genius. Miura is extremely talented in my opinion, not only does he write, he draws the story he created. This isn't like a writer/artist collaboration like American comics. Comparing manga-wise, Berserk has the best artwork I've seen. I personally prefer sketches of Miura's artwork compared to other American artists' sketches.

I am not a fan of Picasso iether but to draw messed up style of his iether he is very very sick or very very genius.


You know whats funny about him, that he was poor most of his life a vagabond living on the little money he made of selling pieces that now go for minium 100 million dollars to the record breaking one of his that sold for 500-600 million dollars.

You know if we're to talk about "Pablo P." i wouldn't say he draws like a "fucking drunk" .Because he is the person who is responsible for the discovery of all kind of art in the 20th century that is,making all other attempts for creating something new absolutely impossible.I'm not only talking about color painting,i mean when i'm saying all i mean everything you can imagine is finished by him.He did draw all kinds of realistic stuff ect. ect.but since he did all that i can understand why he is drawing abstractions.
Uh, and by the way i didn't think or consider Miura a genius but i thought
that many of you would say that he is.And what "sandman"said about what genius would be at many parts is right,but the "art genius" is something completely different,it is a man [not a woman]who has discovered something new,somehing that hasn't been done before,and eventually to reach it's top.