Page 3 of 4

Posted: Fri Dec 23, 2005 2:17 am
by coolerimmortal
One thing, though...I believe Relf's post was sarcastic. No matter, though. Illuminati-Manga has no plans to pick up Berserk. EG is doing an excellent job; much better than the Hawks if I may say so...

Posted: Fri Dec 23, 2005 5:34 am
by Lord Rae
I think if there wasn't such a long wait between the last two chapters we probably wouldn't have issues with the story moving slowly. Granted as has been pointed out its showing growth in that he's not relying on the armor as we were worrying a few chapters ago he might start to....

If I didn't have Berserk manga I don't know if Bleach manga would keep me fullfilled. :P Thanks guys for the speed and dedication to Berserk.

Posted: Fri Dec 23, 2005 7:47 am
by Eldo
newbified wrote:As well the Hawks have even thanked EG for their release of the prototype chapter :).

As well something that probably stirred up feelings from some members is the reply of:
Relf wrote:With the way Evil_Genius is going (2 days late now...) you wonder if they dropped it....
People need to realize that people have lives as well. And someone getting bent out of shape and jumping to conclusions over a 2 day span is a little premature and speaks little of what they think of EG.

And of course EG never claimed to own Berserk. All scanlators and fansubbers are technically stealing work, editting, and re-releasing it. But usually there is still honor between thieves avoiding wasting resources to have more than one group scanlate a project if another group is already handling it.

Either way, I'll say again that it was a great release, and thankfully the whole problem that has been caused at parts of this thread were resolved rather peaceably.
That was one of the few posts in that thread I wasn't really happy about, and there were a couple others in there. I hope people don't think we've dropped Berserk if we'll a couple of days late. We usually give explanations to the delay in the forums anyway, if not the blog post in our website. Seriously, if you want to work on any of the manga projects we have by editing or translating, join EG. That would usually help our releases stay consistent and speedy. I think that is a better option than having another group do it, that way there will be no ill will or misinterpretation with that. EG was founded with Berserk, that suggests it holds high regard within our hearts and it WILL NOT BE DROPPED UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. Oro and I, with the rest of the group will try to ensure that the chapters will be on time, but delays are inevitable if we're both are too busy with RL coincidentally at the same time. Oh, we need translators, for real.

Now that this is all resolved, I'd like to return to topic by saying this chapter rocks. I don't think the current progression has slowed down at all, I enjoyed the plot development very much, and now we have a better understanding of Farnese and Serpico's character, especially how much change Farnese has undergone during her journey with Guts. Oh, and we also got to meet the parents. Yay.

Posted: Fri Dec 23, 2005 1:54 pm
by Libaax
coolerimmortal wrote:
Oro wrote:And also i would like to make fun of this retarded group called lluminati-manga who thought they could steal berserk from us,just like they did Gantz form shockwave,Naruto form Inane and OP from Null.Why do i call them retarded,they are pretty decent...cuz they posted on there forums that they want to do berserk and thought we will never find out or we cant scanlate faster than them,what a bunch of dumbasses.

heres the thread:

http://www.illuminati-manga.com/forums/ ... d.php?t=15

edit: sorry oro, had to add this in. Don't go bashing on their forums, it is just rude. -- psi29a


What a fool you are. As the leader of Illuminati-Manga I'd like to clear a few things up:

1) We stole no projects. Shocwave is slow as hell and we formed on a Gantz forum, hence the reason we're doing Gantz. Inane hasn't released in weeks and we picked up the project as part of an agreement to get a server. OP was a test which was accidentally released...and I subsequently dropped the project.

2) I vetoed Berserk. It's my favorite series and I'm satisfied with EG's releases. If in the future EG begins to experience problems I might consider picking it up but for now Illuminati-Manga has no plans to pick up Berserk.

3)
Libaax wrote:Haha what fools think they can steal Berserk from EG when they are only a speed subbers. I read thier GANTZ,Naruto cause they are fast but i would never read thier Berserk cause the quality diffrence beteween them and EG.


No, what a fool you are for identifying us as speed scanlators. We aren't. Our quality is rather high (it varies depending on the raw). We also have the highest quality Naruto releases of any current group excluding perhaps EOD (we're about even with them at this point), considering Inane and Shannaro have stopped releasing. No other group does Gantz with any speed...Shocwave has the project but they don't seem to understand that no matter how good your quality is if you take a month to release a chapter you fail as scanlators.

Now that I've got all of that cleared up, thanks for the chapter.


Your quality of Naruto and GANTZ is ok but you are speed subbers to me which is good since i dont wanna wait for mangas like those.

EG's Berserk quality is superior to your work of the mangas you guys do.

But hey im a EG fanboy so i might be partial.

Posted: Sat Dec 24, 2005 9:07 am
by coolerimmortal
Libaax wrote:
coolerimmortal wrote:
Oro wrote:And also i would like to make fun of this retarded group called lluminati-manga who thought they could steal berserk from us,just like they did Gantz form shockwave,Naruto form Inane and OP from Null.Why do i call them retarded,they are pretty decent...cuz they posted on there forums that they want to do berserk and thought we will never find out or we cant scanlate faster than them,what a bunch of dumbasses.

heres the thread:

http://www.illuminati-manga.com/forums/ ... d.php?t=15

edit: sorry oro, had to add this in. Don't go bashing on their forums, it is just rude. -- psi29a


What a fool you are. As the leader of Illuminati-Manga I'd like to clear a few things up:

1) We stole no projects. Shocwave is slow as hell and we formed on a Gantz forum, hence the reason we're doing Gantz. Inane hasn't released in weeks and we picked up the project as part of an agreement to get a server. OP was a test which was accidentally released...and I subsequently dropped the project.

2) I vetoed Berserk. It's my favorite series and I'm satisfied with EG's releases. If in the future EG begins to experience problems I might consider picking it up but for now Illuminati-Manga has no plans to pick up Berserk.

3)
Libaax wrote:Haha what fools think they can steal Berserk from EG when they are only a speed subbers. I read thier GANTZ,Naruto cause they are fast but i would never read thier Berserk cause the quality diffrence beteween them and EG.


No, what a fool you are for identifying us as speed scanlators. We aren't. Our quality is rather high (it varies depending on the raw). We also have the highest quality Naruto releases of any current group excluding perhaps EOD (we're about even with them at this point), considering Inane and Shannaro have stopped releasing. No other group does Gantz with any speed...Shocwave has the project but they don't seem to understand that no matter how good your quality is if you take a month to release a chapter you fail as scanlators.

Now that I've got all of that cleared up, thanks for the chapter.


Your quality of Naruto and GANTZ is ok but you are speed subbers to me which is good since i dont wanna wait for mangas like those.

EG's Berserk quality is superior to your work of the mangas you guys do.

But hey im a EG fanboy so i might be partial.
It's worth noting that the raws EG works with are of much better quality than the raws we work with. But I'd rather not start a quality war so I'll leave it at that.

Posted: Sat Dec 24, 2005 11:53 am
by Oro
The guy has apologized for his group's behavior and that was all i was looking for,just end this discussion and talk about chapter 266.

Posted: Sat Dec 24, 2005 3:46 pm
by Sortep
ah thank you great ones at mindwerks... i bow my head in awe of the modhandliness :stupid:

Posted: Sat Dec 24, 2005 5:31 pm
by |||||||
Another fine release...thanks again.

Interesting Chapter. Roderick is becoming more and more similar to jerome...from his behavior and how he works with Ishidoro. :o Well but no wonder Farneze brother isn't respected by his father since he is such a wimp. I don't think guts used the impact to jump to the top of the building, but let himself get busted through the wall to use the stairs inside...it also seems that the armor besides her berserker-abilities is offering great protective effect. Besides I wonder if it'll wear down. I bet the fight will be short and bloody and perhaps we can finally see the elf-king in action soon...

Finally a real world Merry Christmas! 8)

Posted: Sat Dec 24, 2005 8:51 pm
by Loeviz
The elf-king in action you say. Hmm, I´m actually picturing him as a big fat guy that does nothing else then running his mouth when someone visit´s him :D

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 3:32 am
by paulino
Who is the elf king anyways?
Me my persoanl thought about the elf king is the skull knight. Why? cuz he smell elf when pcuk first saw him. And puck also said something like:"strange i remmeber seing him somewhere". Anywyas, im sure that i am very wrong abut this.

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 3:57 am
by Buzkashi
The elfen king is starnum duh. Fuckin n00b.

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 6:37 am
by Lord Rae
I thought puck noticing Elf Smell was from hanging out in the Witchs lair and around the other elf?

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 6:46 am
by Eldo
I wouldn't take most of the things Puck says seriously. He's an idiot. There has been some theories, however, to suggest that Skull Knight is Gaiseric. Unless the Elven King is Gaiseric, I can't see any connection that ties Skull Knight with the Elven King, beside the Elven scent that Puck detected before. It's possible that Skull Knight had gone to the Elven King for help in the past, and is now directing Guts and the party to Elfhelm knowing fully well that this journey would be beneficial to Guts from prior knowledge and past experience.

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 5:05 pm
by Libaax
Puck is a joker but he is serious when he talks about his kind.

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 8:09 pm
by Loeviz
Indeed Puck seem´s dead serious when he talks about Elfhelm.

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 9:40 pm
by Sortep
i dont know if anyone has said this... im too lazy to check... but i have been thinking puck might be the son of the elf king... but who knows

Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 10:08 pm
by Loeviz
Sortep wrote:i dont know if anyone has said this... im too lazy to check... but i have been thinking puck might be the son of the elf king... but who knows
I think I stated the possibility when Puck name dropped Elfhelm the first time.
But I think we came to the conclusion that it´s unlikely since he would probably brag about it all the time

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 1:29 am
by Libaax
Maybe Puck did something that made him leave his kingdom,something he is ashamed of sharing with the others.

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 1:29 am
by Buzkashi
Jar Jar Binks?

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 3:31 am
by Istvan
Maybe Puck did something that made him leave his kingdom,something he is ashamed of sharing with the others.
I'm trying to picture Puck being ashamed (of anything) and I'm coming up blank. I just don't see him as the kind of person who gets ashamed, or who would do anything that he would feel ashamed about later.

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 5:01 am
by Libaax
Buzkashi wrote:Jar Jar Binks?
I didnt watch much of the crappy new Star Wars.

Whats your point that Jar is like Puck?

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 8:22 am
by Loeviz
Puck isn´t clumsy and stupid like Jar jar (I really hated Jar Jar in the new star wars, made them suck even more then they already did).
And if Puck really has done something that got him kicked out from Elfhelm, why did he propose the idea to begin with if he know´s he´s not welcome there any longer?

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 10:50 am
by |||||||
He might have not thought about it...

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 2:45 pm
by Libaax
Or maybe he thought helping his best friend aka Guts would be worth going back and face the music.

Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 3:54 pm
by Loeviz
Libaax wrote:Or maybe he thought helping his best friend aka Guts would be worth going back and face the music.
Perhaps, but he would be a little jumpy by now then